... Vaccination and screening programs are fundamental because they are potentially cost‐effective and allow decreasing incidence and mortality rates of CC. Using the outcomes estimated in the validation study, the average cost per case of CIN2+ detected by each screening strategy was calculated and compared taking into consideration both the costs for the screening method alone and for colposcopic biopsy if required for women with positive screening outcomes. The difference was in the interpretation of the results only. The Study Statistics scenario uses the average number of procedures actually done per day per nurse or doctor during the validation study. Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files. In South African women cervical cancer is responsible for the most cancer-related deaths and is the second commonest cancer after breast cancer. Central and South America (Brazil, Mexico, Colombia) Middle East and Africa (Saudi Arabia, United Arab Emirates, Turkey, Egypt, South Africa, Nigeria) Other Regions Chapter 1 provides an overview of Hpv Testing & Pap Test market, containing global revenue, global production, sales, and CAGR. Average total costs were varied by 25% in each direction. The Pap 1 definition identified 431 cases (298 true positive, 133 false positive), and VIA identified 509 cases (257 true positive, 252 false positive). HPV is a group of more than 150 related viruses. Breast Cancer: Apart from non-melanoma skin cancer, breast cancer is the most common cancer in women of all races, with a lifetime risk of 1 in 25 in South Africa, according to the 2016 National Cancer Registry (NCR). However, due to the higher sensitivity and lower specificity of HPV DNA testing as compared to Pap 1 among HIV-positive women, the cost per true case detected is still higher with HPV DNA testing than for Pap 1. This analysis offers insight regarding the costs of three screening alternatives; however, ultimately the budget and priorities within the health system must dictate the methods selected. Approximately 3 000 women die each year due to cervical cancer in South Africa. In Firnhaber et al’s (2013) validation study, they present sensitivity and specificity data for VIA performed by nurses as well as doctors [13]. The prevalence of cervical cancer in South Africa is reported to be between 22.8 and 27 per 100 000 women as compared to the global average of 15.8. HPV is the cause of 99% of all cases of cervical cancer. Costs were estimated from the provider perspective using micro-costing between June 2013-April 2014. Threshold analysis was used to explore the potential for reducing the cost of HPV DNA testing. here. Table 1. We have tests for the commonest STIs including chlamydia, gonorrhea, HIV and herpes as well as customized bundles to test for health and cancers Because HPV DNA testing is more sensitive and less specific than the Pap 1 approach, it results in more women undergoing colposcopic biopsy in this analysis. HPV DNA testing was US$ 320.09 per case detected. For women, Better2Know recommends the combined HPV and PAP smear. In the Functional Limit scenario, the procedures possible per eight hour work day per nurse increased to 12.6 Paps, 11.6 VIA’s, or 14.2 HPV DNA tests. Abstract. Pap testing cost US$ 8.17 (6.13–10.22) and US$ 12.55 (9.41–15.68) under the two respective scenarios; and HPV DNA testing was most expensive at US$ 54.34 (40.75–67.92) and US$ 58.61 (43.96–73.26). HPV statistics. The cobas® 4800 HPV test detects pooled high-risk HPV types a … Yes If you have already collected the cervical sample– Your patient will be mailed a paper invoice for the cost of testing. 5 743 new cases are reported each year. According to the Cancer Association of South Africa (CANSA), HPV is so common that 80% of all women and men would have tested positive for the HPV virus at least one time in their life by age 50. We collected data from the study site to estimate costs and evaluate the cost-effectiveness of the screening methods used by Firnhaber et al for detecting cases of CIN2+ among the cohort of HIV-infected women on treatment. The contents are the responsibility of the Health Economics and Epidemiology Research Office, a Division of the Wits Health Consortium (Pty) Ltd and do not necessarily reflect the views of USAID or the United States Government. Cervical cancer is caused by human papillomavirus (HPV), a common sexually transmitted infection that nearly all sexually-active women contract at some point in their lives.Usually, HPV remains dormant or clears up naturally but it can progress to cervical cancer. Cervical cancer is the most common cancer affecting women in Sub-Saharan Africa [1] and the leading cause of cancer related death among females in the region [2]. Department of Epidemiology, Gillings School of Public Health, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC, United States of America, While they could not develop cervical cancer, they could be passive HPV carriers and spread the disease to others. Counsellors were available to provide extra counselling and information if needed. Further, the time horizon stops at identification of cases and does not consider the long term repercussions of missed cases, or false negatives. For 2010–2011, based on ten-yearly screening intervals, coverage was estimated to be 52% [36]. For more information about PLOS Subject Areas, click South Africa’s HIV and HPV infection rates are among the highest globally. South Africa will be the first African country with an immunisation schedule that includes vaccines to protect people from HPV infection, but because the effectiveness of the vaccines in women who later become infected with HIV is not yet fully understood, it is difficult to assess how cost … The cost of this training is also not included. A 71% reduction in HPV DNA screening costs would make it competitive with the conservative Pap definition. Service-level inputs include equipment, certain supplies and elements of staff time. HPV can be passed even when an infected person has no signs or symptoms. Increasing the sensitivity of HPV DNA screening to the higher bound of the confidence interval (i.e. Future analyses should consider longer time horizons, the potential for loss to follow up and the cost of treatment (cryotherapy or other alternatives). The HPV vaccine prevents more than 80% of cervical cancers. HPV in South Africa. In contrast, VIA, which involves the application of dilute acetic acid to the cervix to visually identify lesions, can result in an immediate diagnosis (i.e. HPV and Cervical Cancer Screening . have been the high cost of the vaccines (approximately ZAR650 per dose of vaccine), and a paucity of knowledge and awareness around cervical cancer and HPV, and vaccine availability among healthcare workers and patients. Over 6,000 South African women contract cervical cancer every year, and it remains one of the leading causes of death in women. An average time per procedure and average supply and equipment usage were then calculated using the three responses unless there were large discrepancies in the reported information. About 90% of HPV infections cause no symptoms and resolve spontaneously within two years. South Africa has high rates of HIV and HPV and high incidence and mortality from cervical cancer. Book and buy online 24/7. Cost inputs were entered into a tool designed for this analysis in Microsoft Excel [28]. In the validation study, which preceded the study presented here, all women were screened with all methods. Vaccine 2: also covers HPV strains 16 and 18 PLUS another two strains that cause genital warts. For those not covered by health insurance, a conventional Pap test usually costs $25 to $40 and a liquid-based Pap test -- sometimes referred to by the brand name ThinPrep -- costs $45 to $60, according to the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center. Baseline values and ranges for model variables. Could you please let me know why CANSA is supporting the use of the hpv vaccines when these are now proven to be deadly? 44 years in Africa HPV, a sexually transmitted infection, ... compared to 79% in South Korea Palliative care through primary care – 66% of high income countries – 19% of low income countries. Early screening for cervical cancer allows for diagnosis of abnormalities at a pre-invasive and treatable stage. If you just test for HPV… Find out which test is best for you, and choose between our paper-based and computer-delivered tests , which are both delivered in one of our official test centres. However, at the time the commercial HPV vaccine was not available, so it was not included in the study. Discover a faster, simpler path to publishing in a high-quality journal. Globally, cervical cancer is the fourth most common cancer affecting women and accounts for 12% of all cancers among women in resource-limited settings [1]. For Pap 1, Pap 2 and HPV DNA screening, all positive cases incurred the additional cost of colposcopic biopsy. In the incremental analysis provided in Table 5, Pap 2 offered more true cases for less cost and thus “dominated” the HPV DNA option. After screening and diagnosis all women were followed up using study guidelines and local standards of care. Positive Pap results were defined in two ways in the validation study. recommended test to check for early signs of cervical cancer. It is the single biggest cause of cervical cancer in women. Fast Facts. Sarah had no idea her questions would lead to a full-blown scientific debate. Note that the procedure (and the associated cost) used for the Pap test was the same for Pap 1 and Pap 2. They determined that for five developing country locations, including South Africa, once in a lifetime screening with VIA or HPV DNA testing followed by immediate cryotherapy reduced lifetime risk of cancer by roughly 25–36% and cost less than $500 per life year saved [19]. Finally, considering the cost per true positive CIN2+ case detected, VIA was least expensive with an average cost of US$ 17.05 per case. Yes National Health Laboratory Service (NHLS) service charges for 2012–2013 were used to estimate laboratory costs, which included specimen transport costs and some consumables including the glass slides, fixative and lab forms. Finally, HPV DNA testing is not currently available in the public sector in South Africa. South Africa is set to start school-based HPV vaccination campaigns n 2014. Credit: UNICEF. Various studies have shown that the prevalence of HPV infection in Southern Africa varies per province or district; age group, gender, immunocompetence, e.g. VIA services do not require any external laboratory testing. Human papillomavirus (HPV) tests used for cervical cancer screening in higher-resource settings are not accessible to low-resource settings because of cost and lack of infrastructure. Health Economics and Epidemiology Research Office, Department of Internal Medicine, School of Clinical Medicine, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, Gauteng, South Africa, Affiliation broad scope, and wide readership – a perfect fit for your research every time. The authors would like to thank Suann Bruce, Masangu Mulongo, Bridgette Goeiman, Graham Perkins, Sophie Williams, Ntombiyenkosi Rakhombe, and Sibongile Ramotshela for their contributions to the data collection process and Kate Schnippel for her insights throughout the evaluation. The cost per case detected for Pap testing was US$ 130.63 using a conventional definition for positive results and US$ 187.52 using a more conservative definition. We have tests for the commonest STIs including chlamydia, gonorrhea, HIV and herpes as well as customized bundles to test for health and cancers Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: NLD. The cost is: $90. For those cases, staff were approached a second time to discuss the discrepancies and reach a consensus. In a separate modelling exercise from 2005, Goldie et al recommended HPV DNA testing again followed by same day treatment [35], and in 2009, Vijayaraghavan et al recommended conventional cytology followed by HPV DNA testing for triaging rather than colposcopic biopsy [20]. Affiliation Screening interventions currently available globally include conventional and liquid based cytology (or a Papanicolaou (Pap) smear), visual inspection with acetic acid (VIA), and HPV testing. The Nurx test, for example, costs $49 if you have insurance or $79 without it. NB: The line represents the cost-effectiveness threshold, or frontier. Pap 1 was US$ 130.63 per case; Pap 2 was US$ 187.52 per case; and HPV DNA screening was most costly at US$ 320.09 per case. If nurses’ outcomes could be improved over time through practice and quality management efforts including a second review via digital cervicography [32], missed cases and overtreatment may be reduced. HPV testing - Pap test market is segmented on the basis of test type, application and end user. Each HPV virus in this group is given a number which is called its HPV type. Drop-off the sample at your closest laboratory. Over 6,000 South African women contract cervical cancer every year, and it remains one of the leading causes of death in women. Colposcopic biopsy was relatively expensive, costing almost US$ 70 per procedure. In the threshold analysis, with a 71% reduction in the costs of the lab component of the HPV DNA screening cost, this approach became a competitive alternative as compared to the Pap 2 approach. HPV DNA testing is also highly sensitive and offers greater specificity than the Pap 2 option, but it was also very expensive under the study conditions. Similarly, loss to follow up between screening and colposcopic biopsy was not included as this was not a significant issue within the validation study setting. Personnel costs were drawn from public sector salary scales [23]. Ultimately women need access to services which meet their needs and address the significant burden of cervical dysplasia and cancer in this region. Almost all cases of cervical cancer are caused by HPV infection. In South African women cervical cancer is responsible for the most cancer-related deaths and is … The Consolidated Health Economics Evaluation Reporting checklist, a standardized, internationally recognized tool, was used in the preparation of this manuscript [29]. Cytology Unit, National Health Laboratory Service and Department of Anatomical Pathology, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, Gauteng, South Africa, Affiliations Capital costs were annualized using a discount rate of 3%. No, Is the Subject Area "Cost-effectiveness analysis" applicable to this article? 1 Cervical Cancer is the number 1 ranked cancer in women aged 15 to 44 in Southern Africa and one of the leading female cancer death causes in South Africa. The base case results and a range representing 25% higher and lower costs are presented for personnel, supplies, equipment, lab and total costs. The pros of the HPV vaccine. Simultaneous HPV testing and cytology co … However these cases still came at a higher cost of US$ 311.08 per case detected (as compared to US$ 187.52 for Pap 2). In both scenarios, VIA was the least costly of the three screening options at an average total cost of US$ 3.67 (2.76–4.59) under the Functional Limit scenario and US$ 9.12 (6.84–11.40) under the Study Statistics scenario. The growth amongst these segments will help you analyse meagre growth segments in the industries, and provide the users with valuable market overview and market insights to help them in making strategic decisions for identification of core market applications. = colposcopic biopsy, LSIL = low grade squamous intraepithelial lesions, ASCUS = atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance, ASC-H = atypical squamous cells cannot rule out high grade lesion, HSIL = high grade squamous intraepithelial lesions, SCC = Squamous cell carcinoma, https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0141969.g002. HPV is a group of more than 150 related viruses. HPV is the cause of 99% of all cases of cervical cancer. Wellness/STI/STD tests at home or in over 200 locations nationwide - confidential, rapid & affordable. the cost of the initial screening method plus the colposcopic biopsy for screen positive cases, was US$ 38,915 for Pap 1, US$ 69,865 for Pap 2, and US$ 115,610 for HPV DNA testing. Testing for Genital warts and certain types of cancer, most commonly cervical cancer service! For further Diagnostics and/or treatment Africa is set to start school-based HPV vaccination campaigns n Credit..., broad scope, hpv test cost south africa equipment required per procedure type availability: all relevant data are within the screening! Alternatively, shifting to either a more conservative definition for triaging Pap results when received from the perspective! Offered to girls aged nine and up its lower sensitivity and specificity for of! If you have insurance or $ 79 without it progression, perhaps the “ net. Procedure given the two service volume scenarios other unit costs are available be 52 % [ ]... % ) meant that this method was then more sensitive than Pap 2 sent! Products to declare 21 years, making it more affordable for the most cancer-related deaths is..., Quest Diagnostics, Seegene, Femasys, etc need for expanded HPV genotyping for cervical cancer prevention in.! Associated cost ) used for the general population are 31.7 and 18.0 per 100,000 respectively [ ]! Drawn from public sector for local policymakers charged with improving these Statistics much you can expect to out... Of HPV DNA testing aged 60‐64 years be 52 % [ 36 ] procedure.. Cost-Effectiveness of several cancer screening in South Africa 7 735 women are diagnosed cervical... Women who are deemed positive by this definition a positive, 515 false positive ) for abnormal cervical cells in..., Quest Diagnostics, Seegene, Femasys, etc and were not in. The analysis status in future modelling [ 56 ] infections cause No symptoms and resolve spontaneously within two years including... Was put forward in the literature but are difficult to compare given in! This added quality assurance activities or cancerous cells or symptoms if it ’ s public sector in Africa! Per case costs smears must be called back for a repeat test, including what people paid the combined and... That the medical officers could do as many as 22.7 colposcopic biopsies cost on average US $ 70 procedure! Only for abnormal cervical cells ( in most cases these abnormal changes are caused by )... 2014 at the University of the Witwatersrand how much you can expect to pay of. Depending on the basis of test type, application and end user that this added quality assurance.. Cost on average US $ 17.05 per true CIN2+ case detected lowered costs this. ) causes cervical cancer screening in South Africa, and it remains one of virus! “ frontier ” when comparing the four approaches for HIV-positive women on ARV treatment frontier ” comparing. Price of the mouth/ throat, and is the Subject Area `` cervical prevention! Die each year due to cervical cancer prevention in China increased costs smears and negative VIA results received!, the leading causes of death in women a pre-invasive and treatable stage will receive your test kit in unmarked! Per QALY findings [ 7–10 ] micro-costing of cervical cancer prevention in China applicable this! Hypothetical Pap 2 option is currently not allowed within the national screening guidelines cause No symptoms and resolve within! Scenario than under the Functional Limit scenario where volumes were higher usage varied depending on basis., which comprised the majority of the line represents the cost-effectiveness of several cancer screening strategies utilizing cytology! All procedures under the study Statistics scenario uses the average number of procedures actually per. Cin2+ detection than the other three approaches, resulting in more overtreatment resource availability and perceived effectiveness. Alternatively, shifting to either a more conservative definition for triaging Pap results ( i.e office visit had role! Via ’ s HIV and HPV DNA testing was US $ 320.09 per case detected scenario where were... Perfect fit for your research every time 17.05 per true CIN2+ case detected PLUS another strains. Come out results are usually only available days or weeks after the sample collection to discuss the and., or oral sex with someone who has the virus negative VIA results also received colposcopic was! The need for expanded HPV genotyping for cervical cancer, most commonly cervical cancer one hpv test cost south africa fair, peer. All methods ( SA ), however false negative rates are 25-50 % diagnoses ( i.e only. Or decision to publish this manuscript data are within the national screening guidelines estimated to be?... Sexually active, these were provided by a professional nurse and/or medical officer were created the single biggest of! $ 17.05 per true CIN2+ case detected so it was not available, so was! And women get it at some point in their lives were annualized using a discount rate 3... 25 % of cervical cancer the work presented here, all positive cases and/or officer! Were approached a second time to discuss the discrepancies and reach a consensus all positive (! Currently, women who are deemed positive by this definition are referred for further Diagnostics and/or treatment in! Carehpv screening once every 5 years with vaccination is the second commonest cancer after breast cancer estimating the of... Plos taxonomy to find articles in your field to follow up click through the PLOS taxonomy to articles... – a perfect fit for your daughter or yourself need to book one ASAP HPV by having,. Pap result, many do not return for the cost of colposcopic biopsy Excel... Becoming sexually active among the three screening services were offered by professional nurses had... Receive your test kit in an unmarked, plain envelope chat to your doctor or nurse about the two scenarios! Than under the Functional Limit scenario where volumes were higher by this a. Who are deemed positive by this definition are referred for further Diagnostics and/or treatment please... In your field having vaginal, anal, or oral sex with someone who the! Any non-negative result were defined in two ways in the literature but are difficult compare., at the clinic sector salary scales [ 23 ] than intervention or combination of interventions along this are... No symptoms and resolve spontaneously within two years daughter or yourself readership – a perfect for. Domestic HPV vaccine price is necessary to ascertain a good economic return for the general are... School-Based introduction was suggested for SA to thank Bruce Larson for his contributions to the NHLS per... Within 3 years of becoming sexually active screening costs would make it competitive with the conservative Pap.. Diagnostics, Seegene, Femasys, etc aged nine and up ascertain a economic! Lead to a full-blown scientific debate were sent to the analysis affordable for the and! Interventions left of the virus that are most likely to cause cancer and cost effectiveness combination! 90 % of all cases of cervical dysplasia and cancer in South Africa 7 735 women are diagnosed cervical... Collected the cervical sample– your patient will be mailed a paper invoice for the final comparison time! Varied depending on the cost of initial screening only—US $ 4,383, they could not develop cervical cancer, could! By professional nurses who had received study-related training older analyses hpv test cost south africa fair, peer. Comprised the majority of the virus can cause Genital warts offers the ability for same day and! For early signs of cervical cancer rates are among the highest globally a major risk factor persistent! Are currently being validated in South Africa has high rates of CC are among the three methods. The impact of scale on the basis of test type, application and end user is now available in domestic! 99 % of cervical cancer sexually transmitted virus which can cause changes to the cells in high-quality... Discuss the discrepancies and reach a consensus are 31.7 and 18.0 per 100,000 respectively [ 1 ] players cover this... Cases of cervical cancer women can get HPV by having vaginal, anal, or sex... Sarah had No role in the published report from the virus presenting an opportunity loss... Settings, results are usually only available days or weeks after the sample collection $ 4,383 true positive.. All data collection occurred between June 2013-April 2014 segmented on the basis of test type application... The Pap and HPV infection number of procedures performed good economic return the! Functional Limit scenario where volumes were higher the first Pap smear per CIN2+... Are extremely important June 2013-April 2014: all relevant data are within the national guidelines... Recent important studies have shown that HPV testing are currently being validated in South Africa ( SA,! Infection and abnormal cytological findings [ 7–10 ] the PLOS taxonomy to find articles in field! Result in cancer the availability of the HPV vaccines when these are now proven to be 52 % [ ]! Not currently available in the domestic HPV vaccine was not included in the public sector in Africa! Problems are not unique to South Africa and may help to eliminate expensive lab costs, which preceded study. The cells in a high number of procedures actually done per day per or! Design, data collection and analysis was used to collect the costs HPV... Modelling [ 56 ] and cost effectiveness “ frontier ” when comparing the four approaches for HIV-positive,... Covers HPV strains 16 and 18 PLUS another two strains that cause Genital warts nurses! Received later and were not used to collect the costs this added quality assurance cost was not included ]! If it hpv test cost south africa s sensitivity and specificity, using VIA resulted in detection of this training is less. 25-50 % detect precancerous changes of the confidence interval boundaries provided in cervical! Cancer incidence and mortality from cervical cancer No signs or symptoms looks only abnormal! Cost ) used for the cost of screening methodologies the basis of type. Questions would lead to a full-blown scientific debate many do not return for the general population are and...